Since 2017, Ball State and Toledo have met 9 times, and Toledo has the better of it at 7–2.
Most recently Toledo won 39–24 on October 3, 2026.
Right now Ball State is 1–5 and Toledo is 4–2, with Ball State at 32 days since a win against Toledo's 11.
| Date | Site | Winner | Score |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sat, Oct 3 2026 | Ball State home | Toledo | 39–24 |
| Sat, Nov 22 2025 | Toledo home | Toledo | 38–9 |
| Sat, Oct 14 2023 | Ball State home | Toledo | 13–6 |
| Tue, Nov 8 2022 | Toledo home | Toledo | 28–21 |
| Sat, Sep 25 2021 | Ball State home | Toledo | 22–12 |
| Sat, Nov 28 2020 | Toledo home | Ball State | 27–24 |
| Sat, Oct 19 2019 | Ball State home | Ball State | 52–14 |
| Wed, Oct 31 2018 | Toledo home | Toledo | 45–13 |
| Thu, Oct 26 2017 | Ball State home | Toledo | 58–17 |
Full schedules and drought counters: Ball State Cardinals and Toledo Rockets.
Ball State vs Akron, Ball State vs Bowling Green, Ball State vs Buffalo, Ball State vs Central Michigan, Ball State vs Eastern Michigan, Ball State vs Kent State, Ball State vs UMass, Ball State vs Miami (OH), Ball State vs Ohio, Ball State vs Sacramento State, Ball State vs Western Michigan.
Toledo vs Akron, Toledo vs Bowling Green, Toledo vs Buffalo, Toledo vs Central Michigan, Toledo vs Eastern Michigan, Toledo vs Kent State, Toledo vs UMass, Toledo vs Miami (OH), Toledo vs Ohio, Toledo vs Sacramento State, Toledo vs Western Michigan.