| Augsburg Independent | 2–0 | Feb 6, 2026: beat Loras College 45–3 | 251 | Won 2 straight duals |
| Manchester Heartland Collegiate Athletic Conference | 13–3 | Jan 30, 2026: beat Hiram College 43–5 | 258 | Won 4 straight duals |
| Mount Union Independent | 7–2 | Oct 14, 2026: beat Marietta 4–0 | 1 | Won 2 straight duals |
| Bethany (W.Va.) Presidents' Athletic Conference | 16–5 | Feb 12, 2026: beat #25 Gannon 29–18 | 245 | Won 6 straight duals |
| Ithaca Allegheny Mountain Collegiate Conference | 3–1 | Jan 28, 2026: beat Utica University 29–10 | 260 | Lost last dual |
| Alma Michigan Intercollegiate Athletic Association | 3–2 | Dec 19, 2025: beat Carthage College 29–17 | 300 | Won 2 straight duals |
| Alvernia Middle Atlantic Conferences | 7–5 | Oct 14, 2026: beat Widener University 1–0 | 1 | Won last dual |
| Norwich New England Wrestling Assn | 7–5 | Feb 8, 2026: beat New England College 25–24 | 249 | Lost last dual |
| Mount St. Joseph Heartland Collegiate Athletic Conference | 4–3–1 | Oct 14, 2026: beat Hanover College 2–1 | 1 | Won last dual |
| Otterbein Ohio Athletic Conference | 9–8 | Jan 30, 2026: beat Hiram College 39–10 | 258 | Won last dual |
| Trine Independent | 6–6 | Oct 13, 2026: beat Alma 3–1 | 2 | Lost last dual |
| Arcadia Middle Atlantic Conferences | 4–4 | Feb 13, 2026: beat Delaware Valley University 38–2 | 244 | Won 4 straight duals |
| Adrian Independent | 8–9 | Feb 3, 2026: beat Albion College 36–4 | 254 | Won 3 straight duals |
| Albion Michigan Intercollegiate Athletic Association | 8–11 | Feb 12, 2026: beat Trine 24–9 | 245 | Won last dual |
| Carthage College Conference of Illinois & Wisconsin | 5–8 | Jan 3, 2026: beat Upper Iowa University 36–8 | 285 | Lost 2 straight duals |
| Illinois Wesleyan College Conference of Illinois & Wisconsin | 4–9 | Feb 1, 2026: beat Eureka 32–6 | 256 | Won 2 straight duals |
| Alfred State Allegheny Mountain Collegiate Conference | 3–11 | Dec 6, 2025: beat Penn State Altoona 30–15 | 313 | Lost 5 straight duals |
| UW-Oshkosh Wisconsin Intercollegiate Athletic Conference | 1–7 | Jan 27, 2026: beat Lakeland University 35–14 | 261 | Won last dual |
| Waynesburg Presidents' Athletic Conference | 1–10 | Nov 7, 2025: beat Penn State Altoona 25–20 | 342 | Lost 10 straight duals |
| Albright Middle Atlantic Conferences | 0–0 | None found | – | |
| Augustana (Ill.) College Conference of Illinois & Wisconsin | 0–0 | None found | – | |
| Aurora College Conference of Illinois & Wisconsin | 0–0 | None found | – | |
| Baldwin Wallace Independent | 0–0 | None found | – | |
| Blackburn St. Louis Intercollegiate Athletic Conference | – | Not yet read | – | |
| Central (Iowa) American Rivers Conference | – | Not yet read | – | |
| Chatham Presidents' Athletic Conference | 0–0 | None found | – | |
| Delaware Valley Middle Atlantic Conferences | – | Not yet read | – | |
| Greensboro Independent | 0–4 | None found | – | Lost 4 straight duals |
| Heidelberg Ohio Athletic Conference | 0–7 | None found | – | Lost 7 straight duals |
| Huntingdon St. Louis Intercollegiate Athletic Conference | – | Not yet read | – | |
| Keystone Independent | 0–0 | None found | – | |
| Loras American Rivers Conference | 0–4 | None found | – | Lost 4 straight duals |
| McDaniel Independent | – | Not yet read | – | |
| Misericordia Middle Atlantic Conferences | – | Not yet read | – | |
| Penn State Altoona Allegheny Mountain Collegiate Conference | – | Not yet read | – | |
| Schreiner St. Louis Intercollegiate Athletic Conference | – | Not yet read | – | |
| Simpson American Rivers Conference | – | Not yet read | – | |
| Wittenberg Independent | – | Not yet read | – | |
| Buena Vista American Rivers Conference | – | Not yet read | – | |
| Buffalo State Allegheny Mountain Collegiate Conference | – | Not yet read | – | |
| Cedar Crest Independent | – | Not yet read | – | |
| Centenary (N.J.) Atlantic East Conference | – | Not yet read | – | |
| Coe American Rivers Conference | – | Not yet read | – | |
| Cornell College Independent | – | Not yet read | – | |
| Dubuque American Rivers Conference | – | Not yet read | – | |
| Eastern Middle Atlantic Conferences | – | Not yet read | – | |
| Elmhurst College Conference of Illinois & Wisconsin | – | Not yet read | – | |
| Elmira Allegheny Mountain Collegiate Conference | – | Not yet read | – | |
| Emmanuel (Mass.) New England Wrestling Assn | – | Not yet read | – | |
| Eureka St. Louis Intercollegiate Athletic Conference | – | Not yet read | – | |
| Gettysburg Independent | – | Not yet read | – | |
| Hiram Presidents' Athletic Conference | – | Not yet read | – | |
| John Carroll Allegheny Mountain Collegiate Conference | – | Not yet read | – | |
| Kean Independent | – | Not yet read | – | |
| Lakeland Independent | – | Not yet read | – | |
| Linfield Northwest Conference | – | Not yet read | – | |
| Luther American Rivers Conference | – | Not yet read | – | |
| Lyon St. Louis Intercollegiate Athletic Conference | – | Not yet read | – | |
| Maine Maritime Academy Independent | – | Not yet read | – | |
| Marymount (Va.) Independent | – | Not yet read | – | |
| McMurry St. Louis Intercollegiate Athletic Conference | – | Not yet read | – | |
| Millikin College Conference of Illinois & Wisconsin | – | Not yet read | – | |
| MSOE College Conference of Illinois & Wisconsin | – | Not yet read | – | |
| Muhlenberg Centennial Conference | – | Not yet read | – | |
| New England New England Wrestling Assn | – | Not yet read | – | |
| North Central College Conference of Illinois & Wisconsin | – | Not yet read | – | |
| Pacific (Ore.) Independent | – | Not yet read | – | |
| Randolph Old Dominion Athletic Conf. | – | Not yet read | – | |
| Southern Virginia Independent | – | Not yet read | – | |
| Ursinus Independent | – | Not yet read | – | |
| Utica Independent | – | Not yet read | – | |
| UW-Stevens Point Independent | – | Not yet read | – | |
| Wartburg American Rivers Conference | – | Not yet read | – | |
| Washington and Jefferson Presidents' Athletic Conference | – | Not yet read | – | |
| Western New England Independent | – | Not yet read | – | |
| Westminster (Mo.) St. Louis Intercollegiate Athletic Conference | – | Not yet read | – | |
| Wilkes Independent | – | Not yet read | – | |
| York (Pa.) Middle Atlantic Conferences | – | Not yet read | – | |