Since the 2017–18 season, Bellarmine and Stetson have met 9 times, and Stetson has the better of it at 5–4.
Most recently Bellarmine won 92–71 on February 5, 2026.
Right now Bellarmine is 0–0 and Stetson is 0–0, with both waiting 224 days since a win.
| Date | Site | Winner | Score |
|---|---|---|---|
| Thu, Feb 5 2026 | Bellarmine home | Bellarmine | 92–71 |
| Mon, Feb 24 2025 | Stetson home | Stetson | 69–67 |
| Sat, Jan 25 2025 | Bellarmine home | Stetson | 81–76 |
| Wed, Feb 7 2024 | Bellarmine home | Stetson | 84–77 |
| Thu, Jan 12 2023 | Bellarmine home | Stetson | 80–51 |
| Thu, Jan 27 2022 | Stetson home | Bellarmine | 72–47 |
| Thu, Mar 4 2021 | Neutral site | Stetson | 73–70 |
| Sat, Jan 23 2021 | Bellarmine home | Bellarmine | 76–65 |
| Fri, Jan 22 2021 | Bellarmine home | Bellarmine | 67–62 |
Full schedules and drought counters: Bellarmine Knights and Stetson Hatters.
Bellarmine vs Florida Gulf Coast, Bellarmine vs Jacksonville, Bellarmine vs Lipscomb, Bellarmine vs North Florida, Bellarmine vs Queens University, Bellarmine vs West Florida.
Stetson vs Florida Gulf Coast, Stetson vs Jacksonville, Stetson vs Lipscomb, Stetson vs North Florida, Stetson vs Queens University, Stetson vs West Florida.