Since the 2017–18 season, Mercyhurst and Wagner have met 4 times, with Mercyhurst holding a 3–1 edge in the series.
Most recently Wagner won 83–80 on February 19, 2026.
Right now Mercyhurst is 0–0 and Wagner is 0–0, with Wagner at 224 days since a win against Mercyhurst's 221.
| Date | Site | Winner | Score |
|---|---|---|---|
| Thu, Feb 19 2026 | Mercyhurst home | Wagner | 83–80 |
| Sat, Jan 10 2026 | Wagner home | Mercyhurst | 70–69 |
| Fri, Jan 24 2025 | Mercyhurst home | Mercyhurst | 71–66 |
| Sat, Jan 18 2025 | Wagner home | Mercyhurst | 69–65 |
Full schedules and drought counters: Mercyhurst Lakers and Wagner Seahawks.
Mercyhurst vs Central Connecticut, Mercyhurst vs Chicago State, Mercyhurst vs Fairleigh Dickinson, Mercyhurst vs Le Moyne, Mercyhurst vs Long Island University, Mercyhurst vs New Haven, Mercyhurst vs Stonehill.
Wagner vs Central Connecticut, Wagner vs Chicago State, Wagner vs Fairleigh Dickinson, Wagner vs Le Moyne, Wagner vs Long Island University, Wagner vs New Haven, Wagner vs Stonehill.