Since the 2025 season, American International and St. Thomas Aquinas have met 5 times, and St. Thomas Aquinas has the better of it at 5–0.
Most recently St. Thomas Aquinas won 3–1 on March 21, 2026.
Right now American International is 2–21 and St. Thomas Aquinas is 12–14, with American International at 207 days since a win against St. Thomas Aquinas' 178.
| Date | Site | Winner | Score |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sat, Mar 21 2026 | American International home | St. Thomas Aquinas | 3–1 |
| Sat, Mar 14 2026 | St. Thomas Aquinas home | St. Thomas Aquinas | 3–0 |
| Fri, Apr 18 2025 | St. Thomas Aquinas home | St. Thomas Aquinas | 3–0 |
| Sat, Mar 29 2025 | American International home | St. Thomas Aquinas | 3–0 |
| Sat, Mar 1 2025 | St. Thomas Aquinas home | St. Thomas Aquinas | 3–0 |
Full schedules and drought counters: American International Yellow Jackets and St. Thomas Aquinas Spartans.
American International vs Dominican (NY), American International vs Roberts Wesleyan.
St. Thomas Aquinas vs Dominican (NY), St. Thomas Aquinas vs Roberts Wesleyan.