Since the 2025–26 season, Long Island University and St. Anselm have met 4 times and split them evenly at 2–2.
Most recently Long Island University won 3–2 on February 7, 2026.
Right now Long Island University is 2–3–1 and St. Anselm is 0–2, with St. Anselm at 229 days since a win against Long Island University's 2.
| Date | Site | Winner | Score |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sat, Feb 7 2026 | Long Island University home | Long Island University | 3–2 |
| Fri, Feb 6 2026 | Long Island University home | Long Island University | 3–2 |
| Sat, Nov 15 2025 | St. Anselm home | St. Anselm | 8–2 |
| Fri, Nov 14 2025 | St. Anselm home | St. Anselm | 2–1 |
Full schedules and drought counters: Long Island University Long Island University and St. Anselm Hawks.
Long Island University vs Assumption College, Long Island University vs Franklin Pierce, Long Island University vs Post University, Long Island University vs Sacred Heart, Long Island University vs Saint Michael's, Long Island University vs Stonehill.
St. Anselm vs Assumption College, St. Anselm vs Franklin Pierce, St. Anselm vs Post University, St. Anselm vs Sacred Heart, St. Anselm vs Saint Michael's, St. Anselm vs Stonehill.