Since the 2025–26 season, Sacred Heart and St. Anselm have met 6 times, and St. Anselm has the better of it at 4–1–1.
Most recently St. Anselm won 3–1 on February 28, 2026.
Right now Sacred Heart is 1–5 and St. Anselm is 0–2, with St. Anselm at 229 days since a win against Sacred Heart's 3.
| Date | Site | Winner | Score |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sat, Feb 28 2026 | St. Anselm home | St. Anselm | 3–1 |
| Fri, Feb 27 2026 | St. Anselm home | St. Anselm | 3–2 |
| Sat, Jan 24 2026 | Sacred Heart home | Tie | 0–0 |
| Fri, Jan 23 2026 | Sacred Heart home | Sacred Heart | 5–2 |
| Sat, Nov 1 2025 | St. Anselm home | St. Anselm | 3–1 |
| Fri, Oct 31 2025 | St. Anselm home | St. Anselm | 4–1 |
Full schedules and drought counters: Sacred Heart Pioneers and St. Anselm Hawks.
Sacred Heart vs Assumption College, Sacred Heart vs Franklin Pierce, Sacred Heart vs Long Island University, Sacred Heart vs Post University, Sacred Heart vs Saint Michael's, Sacred Heart vs Stonehill.
St. Anselm vs Assumption College, St. Anselm vs Franklin Pierce, St. Anselm vs Long Island University, St. Anselm vs Post University, St. Anselm vs Saint Michael's, St. Anselm vs Stonehill.