Since the 2022 season, McNeese and Nicholls have met 20 times, with McNeese holding a 12–8 edge in the series.
Most recently McNeese won 11–3 on May 14, 2026.
Right now McNeese is 33–27 and Nicholls is 25–27, with Nicholls at 170 days since a win against McNeese's 155.
| Date | Site | Winner | Score |
|---|---|---|---|
| Thu, May 14 2026 | Neutral site | McNeese | 11–3 |
| Sun, Mar 1 2026 | Nicholls home | Nicholls | 3–2 |
| Sat, Feb 28 2026 | Nicholls home | McNeese | 11–4 |
| Fri, Feb 27 2026 | Nicholls home | McNeese | 8–1 |
| Sun, Mar 2 2025 | McNeese home | McNeese | 14–3 |
| Sat, Mar 1 2025 | McNeese home | McNeese | 2–1 |
| Fri, Feb 28 2025 | McNeese home | McNeese | 5–1 |
| Sat, May 25 2024 | McNeese home | Nicholls | 15–1 |
| Sat, May 18 2024 | Nicholls home | McNeese | 10–6 |
| Fri, May 17 2024 | Nicholls home | Nicholls | 10–3 |
| Thu, May 16 2024 | Nicholls home | Nicholls | 4–3 |
| Wed, May 24 2023 | Nicholls home | Nicholls | 3–2 |
| Tue, May 9 2023 | Nicholls home | McNeese | 7–3 |
| Sun, Mar 26 2023 | McNeese home | Nicholls | 8–5 |
| Sat, Mar 25 2023 | McNeese home | Nicholls | 8–6 |
| Fri, Mar 24 2023 | McNeese home | McNeese | 8–3 |
| Fri, May 20 2022 | Nicholls home | McNeese | 8–4 |
| Sun, Apr 3 2022 | Nicholls home | Nicholls | 8–7 |
| Sat, Apr 2 2022 | Nicholls home | McNeese | 5–1 |
| Fri, Apr 1 2022 | Nicholls home | McNeese | 2–0 |
Full schedules and drought counters: McNeese Cowboys and Nicholls Colonels.
McNeese vs Houston Christian, McNeese vs Incarnate Word, McNeese vs Lamar, McNeese vs LSU New Orleans, McNeese vs Northwestern State, McNeese vs SE Louisiana, McNeese vs Stephen F. Austin, McNeese vs Texas A&M-Corpus Christi, McNeese vs UT Rio Grande Valley.
Nicholls vs Houston Christian, Nicholls vs Incarnate Word, Nicholls vs Lamar, Nicholls vs LSU New Orleans, Nicholls vs Northwestern State, Nicholls vs SE Louisiana, Nicholls vs Stephen F. Austin, Nicholls vs Texas A&M-Corpus Christi, Nicholls vs UT Rio Grande Valley.