Since the 2017 season, Seton Hall and Villanova have met 3 times, with Seton Hall holding a 2–1 edge in the series.
Most recently Villanova won 11–6 on April 26, 2026.
Right now Seton Hall is 16–30 and Villanova is 19–30, with Seton Hall at 157 days since a win against Villanova's 156.
| Date | Site | Winner | Score |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sun, Apr 26 2026 | Seton Hall home | Villanova | 11–6 |
| Sun, Apr 26 2026 | Seton Hall home | Seton Hall | 3–2 |
| Fri, Apr 24 2026 | Seton Hall home | Seton Hall | 9–3 |
Full schedules and drought counters: Seton Hall Pirates and Villanova Wildcats.
Seton Hall vs Butler, Seton Hall vs Creighton, Seton Hall vs Georgetown, Seton Hall vs St. John's, Seton Hall vs UConn, Seton Hall vs Xavier.
Villanova vs Butler, Villanova vs Creighton, Villanova vs Georgetown, Villanova vs St. John's, Villanova vs UConn, Villanova vs Xavier.