Since the 2017 season, Seton Hall and St. John's have met 9 times, and St. John's has the better of it at 7–2.
Most recently St. John's won 15–3 on April 4, 2026.
Right now Seton Hall is 16–30 and St. John's is 36–26, with Seton Hall at 157 days since a win against St. John's' 140.
| Date | Site | Winner | Score |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sat, Apr 4 2026 | Seton Hall home | St. John's | 15–3 |
| Sat, Apr 4 2026 | Seton Hall home | St. John's | 13–12 |
| Thu, Apr 2 2026 | Seton Hall home | St. John's | 8–2 |
| Sun, May 27 2018 | St. John's home | St. John's | 7–0 |
| Sun, May 27 2018 | St. John's home | Seton Hall | 19–2 |
| Fri, May 26 2017 | St. John's home | St. John's | 3–2 |
| Sun, Apr 30 2017 | St. John's home | St. John's | 2–1 |
| Sat, Apr 29 2017 | St. John's home | Seton Hall | 7–0 |
| Fri, Apr 28 2017 | St. John's home | St. John's | 9–2 |
Full schedules and drought counters: Seton Hall Pirates and St. John's Red Storm.
Seton Hall vs Butler, Seton Hall vs Creighton, Seton Hall vs Georgetown, Seton Hall vs UConn, Seton Hall vs Villanova, Seton Hall vs Xavier.
St. John's vs Butler, St. John's vs Creighton, St. John's vs Georgetown, St. John's vs UConn, St. John's vs Villanova, St. John's vs Xavier.