Since the 2017 season, St. John's and Xavier have met 12 times, with St. John's holding a 8–4 edge in the series.
Most recently St. John's won 17–6 on May 23, 2026.
Right now St. John's is 36–26 and Xavier is 28–30, with Xavier at 151 days since a win against St. John's' 140.
| Date | Site | Winner | Score |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sat, May 23 2026 | Neutral site | St. John's | 17–6 |
| Sun, Apr 26 2026 | Xavier home | Xavier | 16–6 |
| Sat, Apr 25 2026 | Xavier home | St. John's | 8–6 |
| Fri, Apr 24 2026 | Xavier home | St. John's | 12–7 |
| Thu, May 23 2024 | St. John's home | St. John's | 8–7 |
| Sat, May 25 2019 | Xavier home | Xavier | 11–3 |
| Thu, May 23 2019 | Xavier home | St. John's | 2–0 |
| Sun, May 28 2017 | St. John's home | Xavier | 7–6 |
| Thu, May 25 2017 | St. John's home | Xavier | 13–3 |
| Sun, May 14 2017 | St. John's home | St. John's | 15–3 |
| Fri, May 12 2017 | St. John's home | St. John's | 4–3 |
| Fri, May 12 2017 | St. John's home | St. John's | 7–3 |
Full schedules and drought counters: St. John's Red Storm and Xavier Musketeers.
St. John's vs Butler, St. John's vs Creighton, St. John's vs Georgetown, St. John's vs Seton Hall, St. John's vs UConn, St. John's vs Villanova.
Xavier vs Butler, Xavier vs Creighton, Xavier vs Georgetown, Xavier vs Seton Hall, Xavier vs UConn, Xavier vs Villanova.