Since the 2017 season, Butler and St. John's have met 7 times, and St. John's has the better of it at 6–1.
Most recently St. John's won 4–1 on May 16, 2026.
Right now Butler is 20–34 and St. John's is 36–26, with Butler at 158 days since a win against St. John's' 140.
| Date | Site | Winner | Score |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sat, May 16 2026 | St. John's home | St. John's | 4–1 |
| Fri, May 15 2026 | St. John's home | St. John's | 7–2 |
| Thu, May 14 2026 | St. John's home | Butler | 7–3 |
| Fri, May 25 2018 | St. John's home | St. John's | 12–8 |
| Sat, Apr 15 2017 | Butler home | St. John's | 12–3 |
| Fri, Apr 14 2017 | Butler home | St. John's | 5–3 |
| Thu, Apr 13 2017 | Butler home | St. John's | 6–2 |
Full schedules and drought counters: Butler Bulldogs and St. John's Red Storm.
Butler vs Creighton, Butler vs Georgetown, Butler vs Seton Hall, Butler vs UConn, Butler vs Villanova, Butler vs Xavier.
St. John's vs Creighton, St. John's vs Georgetown, St. John's vs Seton Hall, St. John's vs UConn, St. John's vs Villanova, St. John's vs Xavier.