Since the 2022 season, Manhattan and Mount St. Mary's have met 7 times, and Mount St. Mary's has the better of it at 4–3.
Most recently Mount St. Mary's won 7–6 on May 16, 2025.
Right now Manhattan is 20–31 and Mount St. Mary's is 22–26, with both waiting 157 days since a win.
| Date | Site | Winner | Score |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fri, May 16 2025 | Mount St. Mary's home | Mount St. Mary's | 7–6 |
| Sun, Mar 24 2024 | Manhattan home | Manhattan | 5–2 |
| Sun, Mar 24 2024 | Manhattan home | Mount St. Mary's | 9–7 |
| Fri, Mar 22 2024 | Manhattan home | Mount St. Mary's | 11–8 |
| Sun, May 7 2023 | Manhattan home | Mount St. Mary's | 15–10 |
| Sat, May 6 2023 | Manhattan home | Manhattan | 9–7 |
| Fri, May 5 2023 | Manhattan home | Manhattan | 5–0 |
Full schedules and drought counters: Manhattan Jaspers and Mount St. Mary's Mountaineers.
Manhattan vs Canisius, Manhattan vs Fairfield, Manhattan vs Iona, Manhattan vs Marist, Manhattan vs Merrimack, Manhattan vs Niagara, Manhattan vs Quinnipiac, Manhattan vs Rider, Manhattan vs Sacred Heart, Manhattan vs Saint Peter's, Manhattan vs Siena.
Mount St. Mary's vs Canisius, Mount St. Mary's vs Fairfield, Mount St. Mary's vs Iona, Mount St. Mary's vs Marist, Mount St. Mary's vs Merrimack, Mount St. Mary's vs Niagara, Mount St. Mary's vs Quinnipiac, Mount St. Mary's vs Rider, Mount St. Mary's vs Sacred Heart, Mount St. Mary's vs Saint Peter's, Mount St. Mary's vs Siena.