Since the 2022 season, Mount St. Mary's and Niagara have met 13 times, and Niagara has the better of it at 9–4.
Most recently Mount St. Mary's won 12–5 on May 15, 2026.
Right now Mount St. Mary's is 22–26 and Niagara is 27–21–1, with Mount St. Mary's at 157 days since a win against Niagara's 150.
| Date | Site | Winner | Score |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fri, May 15 2026 | Niagara home | Mount St. Mary's | 12–5 |
| Thu, May 14 2026 | Niagara home | Niagara | 7–6 |
| Wed, May 13 2026 | Niagara home | Mount St. Mary's | 15–4 |
| Sun, Mar 23 2025 | Mount St. Mary's home | Mount St. Mary's | 8–5 |
| Sat, Mar 22 2025 | Mount St. Mary's home | Mount St. Mary's | 12–4 |
| Fri, Mar 21 2025 | Mount St. Mary's home | Niagara | 14–11 |
| Fri, May 24 2024 | Niagara home | Niagara | 8–6 |
| Sun, Apr 14 2024 | Niagara home | Niagara | 9–5 |
| Sat, Apr 13 2024 | Niagara home | Niagara | 15–13 |
| Fri, Apr 12 2024 | Niagara home | Niagara | 16–8 |
| Sat, May 20 2023 | Niagara home | Niagara | 5–2 |
| Fri, May 19 2023 | Niagara home | Niagara | 6–5 |
| Thu, May 18 2023 | Niagara home | Niagara | 9–8 |
Full schedules and drought counters: Mount St. Mary's Mountaineers and Niagara Purple Eagles.
Mount St. Mary's vs Canisius, Mount St. Mary's vs Fairfield, Mount St. Mary's vs Iona, Mount St. Mary's vs Manhattan, Mount St. Mary's vs Marist, Mount St. Mary's vs Merrimack, Mount St. Mary's vs Quinnipiac, Mount St. Mary's vs Rider, Mount St. Mary's vs Sacred Heart, Mount St. Mary's vs Saint Peter's, Mount St. Mary's vs Siena.
Niagara vs Canisius, Niagara vs Fairfield, Niagara vs Iona, Niagara vs Manhattan, Niagara vs Marist, Niagara vs Merrimack, Niagara vs Quinnipiac, Niagara vs Rider, Niagara vs Sacred Heart, Niagara vs Saint Peter's, Niagara vs Siena.