Since the 2022 season, Mercyhurst and Wagner have met 6 times and split them evenly at 3–3.
Most recently Wagner won 8–3 on May 15, 2026.
Right now Mercyhurst is 15–32 and Wagner is 29–24, with Mercyhurst at 158 days since a win against Wagner's 150.
| Date | Site | Winner | Score |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fri, May 15 2026 | Wagner home | Wagner | 8–3 |
| Fri, May 15 2026 | Wagner home | Wagner | 5–4 |
| Thu, May 14 2026 | Wagner home | Mercyhurst | 6–4 |
| Sun, Apr 27 2025 | Mercyhurst home | Mercyhurst | 7–5 |
| Sat, Apr 26 2025 | Mercyhurst home | Mercyhurst | 3–2 |
| Fri, Apr 25 2025 | Mercyhurst home | Wagner | 6–5 |
Full schedules and drought counters: Mercyhurst Lakers and Wagner Seahawks.
Mercyhurst vs Central Connecticut, Mercyhurst vs Coppin State, Mercyhurst vs Delaware State, Mercyhurst vs Fairleigh Dickinson, Mercyhurst vs Le Moyne, Mercyhurst vs Long Island University, Mercyhurst vs Maryland Eastern Shore, Mercyhurst vs New Haven, Mercyhurst vs Norfolk State, Mercyhurst vs Stonehill.
Wagner vs Central Connecticut, Wagner vs Coppin State, Wagner vs Delaware State, Wagner vs Fairleigh Dickinson, Wagner vs Le Moyne, Wagner vs Long Island University, Wagner vs Maryland Eastern Shore, Wagner vs New Haven, Wagner vs Norfolk State, Wagner vs Stonehill.