Since the 2022 season, Stonehill and Wagner have met 13 times, and Wagner has the better of it at 9–4.
Most recently Wagner won 8–4 on April 19, 2026.
Right now Stonehill is 21–28 and Wagner is 29–24, with Stonehill at 156 days since a win against Wagner's 150.
| Date | Site | Winner | Score |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sun, Apr 19 2026 | Stonehill home | Wagner | 8–4 |
| Sat, Apr 18 2026 | Stonehill home | Wagner | 12–5 |
| Sat, Apr 18 2026 | Stonehill home | Stonehill | 5–3 |
| Sat, May 24 2025 | Wagner home | Wagner | 6–4 |
| Sun, Mar 30 2025 | Wagner home | Wagner | 4–2 |
| Sat, Mar 29 2025 | Wagner home | Wagner | 8–3 |
| Fri, Mar 28 2025 | Wagner home | Wagner | 8–2 |
| Sun, Apr 14 2024 | Stonehill home | Stonehill | 4–3 |
| Sat, Apr 13 2024 | Stonehill home | Wagner | 6–5 |
| Sat, Apr 13 2024 | Stonehill home | Stonehill | 12–3 |
| Sun, May 7 2023 | Wagner home | Wagner | 10–1 |
| Sat, May 6 2023 | Wagner home | Stonehill | 7–3 |
| Fri, May 5 2023 | Wagner home | Wagner | 4–3 |
Full schedules and drought counters: Stonehill Skyhawks and Wagner Seahawks.
Stonehill vs Central Connecticut, Stonehill vs Coppin State, Stonehill vs Delaware State, Stonehill vs Fairleigh Dickinson, Stonehill vs Le Moyne, Stonehill vs Long Island University, Stonehill vs Maryland Eastern Shore, Stonehill vs Mercyhurst, Stonehill vs New Haven, Stonehill vs Norfolk State.
Wagner vs Central Connecticut, Wagner vs Coppin State, Wagner vs Delaware State, Wagner vs Fairleigh Dickinson, Wagner vs Le Moyne, Wagner vs Long Island University, Wagner vs Maryland Eastern Shore, Wagner vs Mercyhurst, Wagner vs New Haven, Wagner vs Norfolk State.