Since the 2022 season, Butler and Seton Hall have met 16 times, with Butler holding a 10–6 edge in the series.
Most recently Butler won 11–3 on March 22, 2026.
Right now Butler is 25–21 and Seton Hall is 19–30, with Seton Hall at 174 days since a win against Butler's 165.
| Date | Site | Winner | Score |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sun, Mar 22 2026 | Butler home | Butler | 11–3 |
| Sat, Mar 21 2026 | Butler home | Butler | 8–5 |
| Fri, Mar 20 2026 | Butler home | Butler | 3–0 |
| Sun, Apr 27 2025 | Seton Hall home | Seton Hall | 6–5 |
| Fri, Apr 25 2025 | Seton Hall home | Butler | 4–0 |
| Fri, Apr 25 2025 | Seton Hall home | Butler | 5–3 |
| Thu, May 9 2024 | Butler home | Butler | 9–0 |
| Sat, Mar 30 2024 | Butler home | Butler | 5–2 |
| Fri, Mar 29 2024 | Butler home | Seton Hall | 6–3 |
| Thu, Mar 28 2024 | Butler home | Seton Hall | 2–1 |
| Sun, May 7 2023 | Seton Hall home | Butler | 7–2 |
| Sat, May 6 2023 | Seton Hall home | Seton Hall | 6–2 |
| Fri, May 5 2023 | Seton Hall home | Seton Hall | 2–1 |
| Sun, Mar 27 2022 | Butler home | Butler | 4–1 |
| Fri, Mar 25 2022 | Butler home | Butler | 4–3 |
| Fri, Mar 25 2022 | Butler home | Seton Hall | 8–5 |
Full schedules and drought counters: Butler Bulldogs and Seton Hall Pirates.
Butler vs Creighton, Butler vs DePaul, Butler vs Georgetown, Butler vs Providence, Butler vs St. John's, Butler vs UConn, Butler vs Villanova.
Seton Hall vs Creighton, Seton Hall vs DePaul, Seton Hall vs Georgetown, Seton Hall vs Providence, Seton Hall vs St. John's, Seton Hall vs UConn, Seton Hall vs Villanova.