Since the 2022 season, Seton Hall and Villanova have met 17 times, and Villanova has the better of it at 9–8.
Most recently Seton Hall won 4–0 on April 12, 2026.
Right now Seton Hall is 19–30 and Villanova is 14–39, with Seton Hall at 174 days since a win against Villanova's 169.
| Date | Site | Winner | Score |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sun, Apr 12 2026 | Villanova home | Seton Hall | 4–0 |
| Sat, Apr 11 2026 | Villanova home | Seton Hall | 4–0 |
| Fri, Apr 10 2026 | Villanova home | Villanova | 8–5 |
| Sun, Mar 30 2025 | Seton Hall home | Seton Hall | 4–1 |
| Sat, Mar 29 2025 | Seton Hall home | Villanova | 9–4 |
| Fri, Mar 28 2025 | Seton Hall home | Seton Hall | 3–2 |
| Sun, Mar 10 2024 | Villanova home | Villanova | 7–4 |
| Fri, Mar 8 2024 | Villanova home | Villanova | 6–1 |
| Fri, Mar 8 2024 | Villanova home | Villanova | 5–0 |
| Sat, May 13 2023 | Villanova home | Seton Hall | 6–1 |
| Thu, May 11 2023 | Villanova home | Seton Hall | 9–6 |
| Sun, Apr 30 2023 | Seton Hall home | Seton Hall | 9–1 |
| Fri, Apr 28 2023 | Seton Hall home | Villanova | 4–2 |
| Fri, Apr 28 2023 | Seton Hall home | Villanova | 6–2 |
| Sun, May 1 2022 | Villanova home | Villanova | 5–2 |
| Sat, Apr 30 2022 | Villanova home | Villanova | 3–2 |
| Fri, Apr 29 2022 | Villanova home | Seton Hall | 3–0 |
Full schedules and drought counters: Seton Hall Pirates and Villanova Wildcats.
Seton Hall vs Butler, Seton Hall vs Creighton, Seton Hall vs DePaul, Seton Hall vs Georgetown, Seton Hall vs Providence, Seton Hall vs St. John's, Seton Hall vs UConn.
Villanova vs Butler, Villanova vs Creighton, Villanova vs DePaul, Villanova vs Georgetown, Villanova vs Providence, Villanova vs St. John's, Villanova vs UConn.