Since the 2022 season, Mount St. Mary's and Saint Peter's have met 7 times, and Saint Peter's has the better of it at 4–3.
Most recently Mount St. Mary's won 7–4 on April 29, 2025.
Right now Mount St. Mary's is 20–28 and Saint Peter's is 7–44, with Saint Peter's at 187 days since a win against Mount St. Mary's' 170.
| Date | Site | Winner | Score |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tue, Apr 29 2025 | Saint Peter's home | Mount St. Mary's | 7–4 |
| Tue, Apr 29 2025 | Saint Peter's home | Saint Peter's | 6–1 |
| Sun, Apr 21 2024 | Mount St. Mary's home | Saint Peter's | 13–8 |
| Sat, Apr 20 2024 | Mount St. Mary's home | Mount St. Mary's | 4–3 |
| Sat, Apr 20 2024 | Mount St. Mary's home | Saint Peter's | 7–1 |
| Sun, Apr 16 2023 | Mount St. Mary's home | Mount St. Mary's | 5–4 |
| Sun, Apr 16 2023 | Mount St. Mary's home | Saint Peter's | 9–3 |
Full schedules and drought counters: Mount St. Mary's Mountaineers and Saint Peter's Peacocks.
Mount St. Mary's vs Canisius, Mount St. Mary's vs Fairfield, Mount St. Mary's vs Iona, Mount St. Mary's vs Manhattan, Mount St. Mary's vs Marist, Mount St. Mary's vs Merrimack, Mount St. Mary's vs Niagara, Mount St. Mary's vs Quinnipiac, Mount St. Mary's vs Rider, Mount St. Mary's vs Sacred Heart, Mount St. Mary's vs Siena.
Saint Peter's vs Canisius, Saint Peter's vs Fairfield, Saint Peter's vs Iona, Saint Peter's vs Manhattan, Saint Peter's vs Marist, Saint Peter's vs Merrimack, Saint Peter's vs Niagara, Saint Peter's vs Quinnipiac, Saint Peter's vs Rider, Saint Peter's vs Sacred Heart, Saint Peter's vs Siena.