Since the 2022 season, Saint Peter's and Siena have met 13 times, and Siena has the better of it at 13–0.
Most recently Siena won 7–1 on March 29, 2026.
Right now Saint Peter's is 7–44 and Siena is 25–23, with Saint Peter's at 187 days since a win against Siena's 174.
| Date | Site | Winner | Score |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sun, Mar 29 2026 | Siena home | Siena | 7–1 |
| Sun, Mar 29 2026 | Siena home | Siena | 5–1 |
| Sat, Mar 28 2026 | Siena home | Siena | 5–1 |
| Fri, May 2 2025 | Saint Peter's home | Siena | 11–0 |
| Thu, May 1 2025 | Saint Peter's home | Siena | 11–0 |
| Thu, May 1 2025 | Saint Peter's home | Siena | 7–1 |
| Sun, Apr 28 2024 | Siena home | Siena | 8–3 |
| Sat, Apr 27 2024 | Siena home | Siena | 6–2 |
| Sat, Apr 27 2024 | Siena home | Siena | 6–0 |
| Mon, Apr 3 2023 | Siena home | Siena | 5–0 |
| Mon, Apr 3 2023 | Siena home | Siena | 3–0 |
| Sat, Apr 2 2022 | Saint Peter's home | Siena | 8–1 |
| Sat, Apr 2 2022 | Saint Peter's home | Siena | 5–0 |
Full schedules and drought counters: Saint Peter's Peacocks and Siena Saints.
Saint Peter's vs Canisius, Saint Peter's vs Fairfield, Saint Peter's vs Iona, Saint Peter's vs Manhattan, Saint Peter's vs Marist, Saint Peter's vs Merrimack, Saint Peter's vs Mount St. Mary's, Saint Peter's vs Niagara, Saint Peter's vs Quinnipiac, Saint Peter's vs Rider, Saint Peter's vs Sacred Heart.
Siena vs Canisius, Siena vs Fairfield, Siena vs Iona, Siena vs Manhattan, Siena vs Marist, Siena vs Merrimack, Siena vs Mount St. Mary's, Siena vs Niagara, Siena vs Quinnipiac, Siena vs Rider, Siena vs Sacred Heart.