Since the 2022 season, Sacred Heart and Saint Peter's have met 3 times, with Sacred Heart holding a 3–0 edge in the series.
Most recently Sacred Heart won 7–6 on April 1, 2025.
Right now Sacred Heart is 23–31 and Saint Peter's is 7–44, with Saint Peter's at 187 days since a win against Sacred Heart's 165.
| Date | Site | Winner | Score |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tue, Apr 1 2025 | Sacred Heart home | Sacred Heart | 7–6 |
| Tue, Apr 1 2025 | Sacred Heart home | Sacred Heart | 9–1 |
| Tue, Mar 22 2022 | Sacred Heart home | Sacred Heart | 4–1 |
Full schedules and drought counters: Sacred Heart Pioneers and Saint Peter's Peacocks.
Sacred Heart vs Canisius, Sacred Heart vs Fairfield, Sacred Heart vs Iona, Sacred Heart vs Manhattan, Sacred Heart vs Marist, Sacred Heart vs Merrimack, Sacred Heart vs Mount St. Mary's, Sacred Heart vs Niagara, Sacred Heart vs Quinnipiac, Sacred Heart vs Rider, Sacred Heart vs Siena.
Saint Peter's vs Canisius, Saint Peter's vs Fairfield, Saint Peter's vs Iona, Saint Peter's vs Manhattan, Saint Peter's vs Marist, Saint Peter's vs Merrimack, Saint Peter's vs Mount St. Mary's, Saint Peter's vs Niagara, Saint Peter's vs Quinnipiac, Saint Peter's vs Rider, Saint Peter's vs Siena.